Canvas What-If scores and why your grade does not match your math

Last reviewed: October 28, 2026

If the number Canvas shows is not the number you get with a calculator, a handful of rules Canvas applies can explain the gap, because a simple points total ignores them. Work through them in the order below. Each one is a setting or a label you can check yourself on the Grades page.

What-If scores are your own scratch pad

Open Grades in the course navigation, click the score cell of any assignment, and type a hypothetical score. Canvas recalculates your total using that number. This works on assignments that already have a score and on ones that have not been graded yet.

Canvas describes What-If scores as a simulation. Only students can enter and view them, and instructors cannot create hypothetical scores for a student. They never replace your real score. To go back, click Revert to Actual Score in the sidebar. A Show Saved What-If Scores button brings back any What-If scores you have tested in that course.

The practical risk is forgetting you typed one. If your total looks too good or too bad, revert before you compare anything.

Current grade and total grade are different numbers

Canvas always calculates two grades. The current grade uses only graded assignments. The total grade uses all assignments, graded or not.

The Calculate based only on graded assignments checkbox in the Grades sidebar switches between them. It is selected by default, so the number you see first is the current grade. Clear the checkbox to see the total grade. If your own math includes assignments that are not graded yet, you are probably comparing against the wrong one of the two.

Weighted groups are not a points total

By default Canvas calculates the total from points possible. An instructor can instead weight the final grade by assignment group. Whether that is on is the instructor's choice, so check the sidebar: if your assignment groups are weighted, it shows the weights.

With weighting on, Canvas first works out a percentage inside each group, then multiplies by that group's weight, then adds the groups together. The Canvas guide on weighting gives an example of a group worth 25 points where the student earned 15, which is 60 percent for that group before the weight is applied. Adding up every point in the course will not reproduce the result.

One more effect: when a group has no graded items yet, the Canvas guide says it is removed from the final score calculation, and the groups that do have graded items are divided by their combined weight. That means your grade can shift when the first grade lands in a new group.

Dropped and excused work does not count

Some assignments are in the list but not in the math. Look for these on the Grades page:

  • Grey text. Canvas says this assignment was dropped as part of an assignment group calculation and does not factor into your total score. Instructors can set a group to drop the lowest or highest scores. A drop-lowest rule removes the score or scores that leave the group with the best possible result, and a drop-highest rule does the opposite, so what gets dropped is not always what you would pick by percentage.
  • EX in the score column. The assignment is excused. It cannot be submitted and does not factor into your overall grade.
  • A grade info icon. Points from this assignment do not count toward your final grade. Canvas still says to submit it unless your instructor has excused it.
  • A banner on the assignment. Your instructor has removed it from total grade calculations. This does not affect whether you can submit it.

If your math counts any of these, that explains the difference.

Ungraded, hidden and unposted work

Icons in the score column mean the work is in but has not been scored: a document icon for a file upload, a text icon for a text entry, and similar ones for links, discussions and quizzes. A dash means no submission. A visibility icon means the score is hidden while your instructor is grading, and you will not see the grade, comments or quiz responses until the instructor posts grades for that assignment.

Two other things can hide the picture. Your instructor can hide totals in course settings, in which case you cannot see your current or total grade at all. And if the course uses grading periods, the Grades page opens on the current period, and an assignment with no due date appears in the last grading period. Use the grading period menu and Apply to check the others.

If the math still differs

Before you write to your instructor, revert any What-If scores, then take a screenshot of the Grades page with the sidebar checkbox state visible. Then ask something specific:

  • Are assignment groups weighted, and what are the weights?
  • Does any group drop the lowest or highest scores, and which assignments are excluded from the total?
  • Is a particular assignment scored but unposted, excused, or removed from total grade calculations?
  • Does the syllabus describe a grading scheme that differs from how the course is set up in Canvas?

Instructors build these settings per course, and the syllabus does not always match what was configured. A short, specific question with the assignment names gets a faster answer than "my grade is wrong."